Authored by Michelle David, Ntokozo Ngubane and Francisco Andrade Nobrega.

In a Constitutional Court (the Court) judgment handed down on 9 October 2026 in the matter of GD v Minister of Home Affairs and Others [2026] ZACC 39, the Court unanimously confirmed that section 7(7)(c) of the Divorce Act, 1979 (Divorce Act) is unconstitutional and invalid, in that it excluded a spouse’s pension interest from redistribution on divorce where the marriage was concluded out of community of property and without accrual on or after 1 November 1984.

The main issue for determination was whether, following the Court’s earlier judgment in EB (born S) v ER (born B); KG v Minister of Home Affairs [2023] ZACC 32 (KG), there remained any lawful basis for treating pension interest differently from every other asset in a redistribution claim. For pension funds, administrators and boards of trustees, the answer has direct consequences for the divorce orders they will be called upon to implement.

In this matter the dispute arose out of the divorce between the applicant, Mrs D, and her husband, Mr D:

(1)    On 25 April 2004, Mr and Mrs D were married out of community of property and without accrual. Mrs D alleged that, although she ran her own business projects, her main focus was managing the family and supporting Mr D in his business and personal endeavours, thereby materially contributing to the growth of his estate.

(2)    On 13 October 2020, the marriage having irretrievably broken down, Mrs D instituted divorce proceedings and sought, amongst other things, a redistribution order which included Mr D’s pension interest, relying on KG.

(3)    The difficulty was that, while section 7(7)(a) of the Divorce Act deems a party’s pension interest to be part of his or her assets, section 7(7)(c) of the Divorce Act disapplied that rule for post-1984 marriages out of community of property and without accrual. KG had opened the redistribution remedy in section 7(3) of the Divorce Act to post-1984 marriages, but section 7(7)(c) of the Divorce Act was not challenged in that matter and remained in place, so that any redistribution in Mrs D’s favour would necessarily have excluded Mr D’s pension interest.

(4)    Mrs D therefore challenged section 7(7)(c) of the Divorce Act, contending that it differentiated irrationally between pre- and post-1984 marriages, contrary to section 9(1) of the Constitution, and unfairly discriminated on the grounds of gender and sex, contrary to section 9(3) of the Constitution. The High Court, Eastern Cape Division, Gqeberha, agreed and declared the provision invalid in its entirety, and the matter came before the Court for confirmation. The Minister of Justice abided the decision and filed an affidavit on remedy, while the Minister of Home Affairs declined to participate.

On these aspects, the Court held that;

(1)    KG fundamentally changed the legislative scheme. Assets in all marriages out of community of property and without accrual are now subject to redistribution regardless of when the marriage was concluded, and the exclusion of pension interest alone, unlike any other asset, is “vestigial”. The distinction is no longer connected to any rational purpose and cannot be sustained under section 9(1) of the Constitution.

(2)    The reasoning in KG applies equally to pension interest. The expert evidence showed that women, on average, are expected to retire with approximately 71% of the wealth accumulated by men and to receive only 74% of their retirement income, largely because unpaid domestic and care work frees husbands to advance their careers and build their pensions. Excluding pension interest therefore disproportionately prejudices women and constitutes unfair discrimination which cannot be justified under section 36(1) of the Constitution.

(3)    Unlike in KG, the declaration of invalidity should not be suspended. Section 7(7)(c) of the Divorce Act functions solely to exclude post-1984 marriages from the redistribution of pension assets and serves no constitutionally compliant purpose, and the proposed General (Family) Laws Amendment Bill would in any event remove it entirely. The declaration therefore takes immediate effect, but it is prospective and does not affect finalised divorces or wound-up matrimonial estates.

Of particular interest to the retirement funds industry is the position taken by the Minister of Justice, namely that the outcome has no implications for the Pension Funds Act, 1956 and introduces no new administrative burden on pension funds, as they already implement redistribution orders pursuant to section 7(8) of the Divorce Act. The Minister also stressed that pension interest is not automatically divisible: it simply forms part of the asset pool that a court may consider under section 7(3) of the Divorce Act, subject to judicial discretion and the just and equitable standard.

The outcome in this matter confirms that the post-1984 date of a marriage is no longer a shield for a member’s pension interest on divorce. Where a member is married out of community of property and without accrual, the pension interest is now as exposed to a just and equitable redistribution order as any other asset in the member’s estate.

In practical terms, boards of trustees and administrators should take note that:

(1)    from 9 October 2026, a divorce order awarding part of a member’s pension interest to a non-member spouse in a post-1984 marriage out of community of property and without accrual cannot be resisted or declined on the basis of section 7(7)(c) of the Divorce Act;

(2)    the entitlement is not automatic, and funds should act only on a court order granted under section 7(3) read with section 7(8) of the Divorce Act, rather than on a non-member spouse’s assertion that the pension interest is now divisible;

(3)    the order is prospective, so divorces finalised and matrimonial estates wound up before the judgment are not reopened, and benefits already paid on that basis are not affected; and

(4)    divorce-processing procedures, checklists and member communications that still refer to the post-1984 exclusion should be updated and boards should monitor the progress of the General (Family) Laws Amendment Bill, as the suspension of the KG order has been extended to 10 April 2027.

GD is yet another example of the continually changing legal landscape applicable to the awarding of pension interest. It yet again highlights the need for administration processes that are amenable to change and cognisant of possible flaws in the existing legislative framework. Funds and administrators need to be aware of the impact of the change and make the necessary amendments where necessary.

GD v Minister of Home Affairs and Others [2026] ZACC 39 (CCT 60/25 - 9 October 2026).