Authored by Malcolm Hartwell.
On 20 March 2026, the High Court in London affirmed the long established and well understood principle that the carrier is entitled and obliged to deliver cargo described in the bill of lading to the lawful holder of that bill of lading. The decision itself is unsurprising, but serves as a timely reminder of how important, in this digital age, the original bills of lading are in determining who the carrier must deliver the cargo to.
Comid had sold a consignment of steel to Kama Metal Trading (Kama)on a C&F basis and had contracted with Maersk to carry the cargo and discharge it in Kenya. On loading, Maersk issued three original bills of lading which named Comid as the shipper and Kama as the consignee. The cargo was discharged in Kenya and for reasons which do not appear from the judgment was not immediately released by Maersk to the consignee. This is possibly because there had been a delay by Comid in delivering the original bills of lading to Kama.
Maersk received a demand from Kama on 3 December 2025 stating that it was the lawful holder of the bill lading, the named consignee and was in possession of all three original bills of lading and demanding release of the cargo to it. Later that month, Comid commenced proceedings in the Kenyan courts seeking an interdict against release of the cargo by Maersk to Kama on the basis that, Kama had obtained the original bills of lading by subterfuge. Details of the subterfuge were not provided to the court.
Relying on the choice of law and jurisdiction clause in the bill of lading, Maersk applied to the High Court of Justice in London for directions as to what to do with the cargo.
In a very brief judgment, the court found that, on the face of it, Kama was the consignee and the lawful holder of all three original bills of lading. In the circumstances, Maersk was both entitled and obliged to release the cargo to Kama. The court however declined Maersk’s request that it issue an order permanently barring Comid from instituting proceedings against Maersk under the bill of lading.
The court reached this decision despite accepting that Kama had failed to pay the full purchase price to Comid. The court accepted Kama’s explanation that this was because of defects in the cargo.
In some jurisdictions, including South Africa, Comid could have applied for an order for the arrest of the cargo in order to obtain security for its claim for short-payment, but it appears that this was not possible in Kenya. In addition, in many countries, courts faced with evidence of fraud or subterfuge might be persuaded that the party actually holding the bills of lading was not entitled to do so and in those circumstances, would not have ordered the immediate release of the cargo to the consignee.
This case however remains a timely reminder to traders, financiers and insurers to make sure that the delivery of to order or named consignee bills of lading is in accordance with the contract of sale and any payment obligations.
High Court of Justice London in the Commercial Court. Kama Metal Trading LLC v Maersk and Comid